Can Catholics vote for Obama?

An interesting article points up the huge debate within the Catholic Church regarding the presidential election. The tenets of the faith put pro-life above all else, but it is in the definition of “Respect for Life” that it becomes murky. For me, it is a replay of the election four years ago when my own faith was called into question.

As a life-long Catholic, I struggle too with adhering to my faith in a modern world. The issue is, however, that it is my faith, and not the faith of every other American. What is right for me in my Catholic life cannot be dictated to everyone in a free society. Issues of birth control, abortion and homosexuality are personal, intimate decisions made by individuals of many faiths. I am in agreement that I, in choosing to remain a Catholic, am bound by the tenets of my faith, but others of other faiths have no such obligations.

To say that pro-choice supporters are pro-ABORTION is ludicrous. A woman who must make the difficult decision to end an unwanted pregnancy has to be the one to come to terms with her maker. It is not for me to judge. I would hope that we would be able, through education and support, to reduce the number of abortions so no woman has to live life with that stigma or pain. Obama wants the same thing- to reduce the need for drastic measures like abortion. The church says that’s not enough. To support a pro-life candidate is to support murder.

Speaking of murder, how many soldiers and innocent Iraqis have been murdered since the war began? My Catholic faith teaches me that war and agression is also a sin. In this war, we were not defending ourselves; we were the agressor. How many unwanted and undeserved children are abused or killed every year by parents (some still children themselves) who were not ready or able to devote their lives to the welfare of a child. Parenthood is a huge commitment- a most precious gift-that demands a lifetime of love and caring that many are not able to give. Every child born should be a wanted child.

And so, four years ago, I wrote a letter to the editor of the paper to express my concern that the church, my church, was neglecting the other tenets of our faith to endorse candidates only on the pro-life issue. I pleaded with voters to consider the vast social problems that should be of major concern as well. I wrote about the increasing health costs for seniors, of children with no insurance, of a middle and lower class without the basics of life while corporate America got rich. I begged voters to consider the proliferation of assault weapons on our streets that robbed young lives and the lack of educational footholds to get people out of poverty. Caring for our elderly, disabled and disadvantaged is the basis of Christ’s work and teachings on earth. “Whatever you do for the least of my brothers, you do for me.”  I wonder to this day how much influence my church had on the disaster of an election in 2004 that continued an administration drunk on power and disregard for the real social issues. Look where it got us.

Four years ago my political views called into question my faith and fitness to be a Catholic. One angry woman launched a tirade against my views that caught my parish priest in the middle. Feeling then, as I do now, that only my God knew the depth and breadth of my faith I was bruised by the idea that supporting John Kerry made me unfit to practice my religion. The irony was that I had been teaching adults who were becoming part of the faith and seeking baptism in the Catholic church. I taught them the rules of the church as they are put forth; doctrine is not negotiable. Still, my public expression of personal views regarding politics cast a pall over every aspect of my performance as a Catholic. I used to teach those longing for a life of faith and service to the Lord that no matter what mistakes we made in our lives, the church was the one place where we could come for forgiveness, and for unconditional love. It was hard to know that so many would judge me, and that those who supported me were afraid to express support for fear of the same judgement.

I was a Eucharistic minister, teacher, volunteer and joyful servant of my Catholic church but suddenly it was not good enough. I no longer felt that unconditional love and chose to step away from my faith family so no one had to take sides. Make no mistake about one thing. I may have stopped attending one particular parish but in my heart I remain a Catholic- always. No one can take away my baptism or faith! One day I will be judged for my actions by the only one fit to judge.

So here we are, four years later, and the church is again attempting to guilt Catholics into using the pro-life issue as the barometer for fitness to govern a country in need of a renewed conscience. While they push their doctrine on the 75% of Americans not of the Catholic faith, they are ignoring the social issues that affect the lives of millions of Americans who lack life’s basic necessities. It promotes a party that would rather spend dollars to make war for oil and corporate interests than to work to feed the world’s hungry and oppressed. They ignore the issues of the destruction of our planet and God’s beautiful creations for profit, comfort and greed.

I do not expect the Catholic church, my church, to change their doctrine or to put the stamp of approval on things that go against their teachings. I expect them to stay out of politics entirely and stop playing the God card to guilt otherwise good Catholics who are looking at the broader societal picture. God gave us free will, just as Democracy gives each of us freedom of choice. Noone said there would be no judgement at the end, but the very definition of our faith says there can be no judgement by anyone on earth.


One Response to “Can Catholics vote for Obama?”

  1. pam mccarthy Says:

    I, too, am so conflicted this election. The last 8 years have proven to be more dreadful than I could ever have dreamed! I knew so many christians and catholics who voted for Bush because they truly believed that “finally we have a Godly, pro-life evangelical christian” in the White House.

    I predicted that we would be at war when he took office. Nobody listened to me. Then 9/11 happened. When I heard him make the case for invading Iraq, I protested. And I prayed. And lo and behold, they lied to us again. There were no weapons of mass destruction found. And Sadam Hussein had ZIP to do with 9/11. I even heard Bush say that he “didn’t worry” about Osama Bin Laden anymore after he declared “mission accomplished.”

    He lied to us. He bankrupted our country by leading us into an unjust war, that the Pope was even against!

    I feel strongly pro-life. I was at the Saddleback forum when John McClain declared himself the pro-life candidate of the pro-life party.

    I’m sorry, I just don’t believe them. Ronald Reagan signed the first protection of a woman’s right to choose when he was governor of California. People conveniently forget about that!

    I don’t believe McCain or any of the so-called “pro-life” republicans will push to overturn Roe vs. Wade. For years, they had the majority in the senate and house as well as the White House, but it just wasn’t on their radar. I think it’s too useful for them as a wedge issue.

    But still I pray for the Holy Spirit to guide me as I prepare to vote. I love the Lord, and I love being a Catholic. I think it is sad that you felt as though you had to walk away. I understand why you did.

    I just couldn’t read your blog without commenting. You’re not alone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: